A Rifle And A Bag


On the Bandra-Mahim junction, there is a very famous statue with a quote by Dr V.V. Kamat- ‘A child gives birth to a mother’. The documentary, ‘A Rifle and A Bag’ by Arya Rothe, Cristina Hanes and Isabela Rinaldi amongst other things encapsulate the quote very beautifully. The film is an intimate portrayal of Somi, a former Naxalite who surrendered along with her husband with the hope to provide a better life for their two children. It is based in a camp in interior parts of Maharashtra set up by the government for former Naxalites.

Now, first of all, let me be clear, I know very little about the Naxalism in India but on a simple google search, I found that it is considered as a greater danger than terrorism by the establishment, as it is currently affecting around 22 states of our country. There are polarizing articles almost preaching Pro Naxal and Anti Naxal narratives. I am still trying to understand the various forms of oppression, the origin of it and their current state in our country. Nevertheless, what I think (in all my naivety) is the first step towards fighting any oppression is imparting education and Somi understands it more than we do. That’s what she fights for throughout the film.

But does anyone care, especially when you are on the wrong side of the margin. The powerful make laws and put in systems to pretend that they are helping. But in turn, what they are creating is a more complex maze that will leave the oppressed bewildered. Standing in ATM Lines, Standing in line to prove their identity or walking miles to reach home in a pandemic without adequate food, the biggest sufferers are always the marginalised.

A screenshot from the film

Despite all this, this film rarely catches Somi in a vulnerable state. She sings songs of resilience around the fire every night to find the inner strength to keep up her fight. The silences between the family conversations tell more about the relationship of Somi and her husband (much younger to her) than words could ever express.

One of the most important aspects of a documentary film set up your relationship with the protagonist, both while making and watching. Kudos to the makers for making us believe that we are a part of Somi’s journey. The frames created by the makers also try to supplement what is going on in her mind. The frontal framing seems very deliberate so that Somi looks in control of the situation. Rarely, when she is anxious and uncertain, it is shot in the cramped and dingy space of the camp mostly at night. In the later moments of the film, when she opens up to her son a bit, it is shot in a wide landscape with a picturesque background.

All in all, A Rifle and A Bag somehow tries to break the pro-Naxalite and anti-Naxalite narrative often dangerously looming to the level of propaganda. It presents the problem in a humanistic and relatable manner by showcasing a mother’s journey trying to get the best life for his child.

The filmmakers Arya Roth from India, Isabella Rinaldi from Italy and Cristina Hanes from Romania graduated from the Doc Nomads Program and make films under the banner of ‘NoCut Film Collective’. Here’s hoping their camera remains this honest in their next project and inspire young filmmakers like us.

The online screening of this film is happening worldwide till 7th May on

PS: Thanks to Suyash Kamat for tweeting about it.


Humanity and Films

I don’t really like writing about films, but now I realised that I wasn’t watching the right films. But are there any right or wrong films though? Yes, there are, the films that becomes an experience is a right film. Period. The film that connects to you and lets you get in touch with your humanity again is a right film for you. Getting in touch with your own humanity is a big relief in this highly complex mechanical world. The film which transcends human boundaries of language and culture and is yet grounded beautifully in its own reality is a right film. It is very subjective. Keeping this in mind, I made a list of 5 movies from last year which I thought were RIGHT! Actually, I had existential crisis after watching them. Apart from making me cry in the theatre, these films stayed with me and I don’t think they will ever leave me again. They will hold my hand and inspire me to take baby steps in the world of film making. Though it is a list, please don’t focus on the rank. I will not write about these films but just attaching the links to the trailers here. I will also tell you my crying duration during the film.

#5 Sudani From Nigeria (Malyalam) (India)

Crying Duration: 5-7 minutes
PS: This film is available on Netflix

#4- Manto (Hindi) (India)

Crying Duration: 7-10 minutes
PS: Available on Neflix

#3- Shoplifters (Japanese) (Japan)

Crying Duration- 10 minutes
PS: Watched it in Kolkata International Film Festival

#2- Roma (Mixtec, Spanish) (Mexico, USA)

Crying Duration- 10 minutes
PS: Available on Netflix

#1- Capernaum (Arabic) (Lebanon)

This film makes me cry every time I think about it
PS: I watched it in Kolkata International Film Festival

Special Mention- The Price Of Free (Hindi, English) (India)

Crying Duration: 5 minutes
PS: Available on Youtube

This is my list, please let me know in the comments section which movie made you cry in 2018.